On the night of January 3, Cindy Burnham of Fayetteville, NC, was in her pajamas, leaning over the
sink to brush her teeth, when she heard the garage door rising. That meant her husband, technical
diver and videographer Rick Allen, was home. The next thing she knew, Burnham had been thrown to
the floor several feet back, with shards of glass in her face from the shattered mirror.
She ran to the garage to find her husband. "The door was blown out," Burnham later told the
Fayetteville Observer. "I could see my husband on fire inside the garage." She grabbed a fire extinguisher
to put out the flames on Allen's back, and then called 911. While Burnham only needed 12 stitches to
her face, he was put in critical care at the hospital. One hand had been severed by the blast, his left arm
needed to be amputated at the elbow and he had burns on his legs and back and left side.
The cause of the tragedy: an 80 cu. ft. scuba tank containing 100 percent pressurized oxygen.
According to Steve Burton, a dive equipment technician and editor of ScubaEngineer.com
(www.scubaengineer.com), what apparently happened was the tank was knocked over, either by Allen
walking by or the garage door bumping against it. "That likely hit the valve against something as it toppled
over, and the mechanical shock caused the valve to be explosively ejected, followed milliseconds
later by the fiery detonation of the scuba cylinder."
Note that the tank was an oxygen cylinder, and not a typical diver's compressed air tank. "Rick Allen
was a technical diver trained in the use of pure oxygen to shorten decompression stops after very long dives," says Burton. "I would guess that not even one diver in a thousand keep compressed oxygen cylinders
at home, in comparison with the common compressed-air tanks found worldwide in dive centers."
"That likely hit the valve
against something as it
toppled over, and the
mechanical shock caused the
valve to be explosively ejected,
followed milliseconds later
by the fiery detonation of the
scuba cylinder." |
That may be true, but even the standard diver's air tank can wreak plenty of havoc. For example, two
Polish divers were killed and two others seriously injured
from a tank explosion last September while on a dive trip at
the Croatian island of Vis. Croatia's transport ministry said
the tank exploded while being unloaded from a boat onto
the dock, and the cause of the blast was most likely a poppedout
valve. One woman died on the spot, another died later in
the hospital from head injuries.
Back in August 2009, an Australian dive master lost his
right hand and suffered major injuries to his right leg when
a scuba tank exploded. Murray Amor, the equipment service
manager at South West Rocks Dive Centre near Coffs Harbor,
Australia, was doing a routine refill of the tank when it ruptured
and blew into several pieces, tearing large gouges into
the building's brick walls.
A standard tank can also have a "hammer effect." Larry
Harris Taylor, diving safety coordinator at the University of Michigan, tells his students that a tank
standing alone is a "foot-seeking device" and will most likely fall on the foot of a litigation-seeking
attorney. "A single scuba cylinder typically, depending on the composition material and the volume of
the cylinder, weighs between 30 and 50 pounds," he comments. "This amount of mass can develop a
significant impact force, even when falling only a short distance." On his website, Harris posts photos
(www.mindspring.com/~divegeek/toe.htm) of an injury sustained by a diver when a single steel 72 cu. ft.
tank standing upright next to a wall was accidentally knocked over and fell on his foot. His big toe was
crushed into multiple fragments, and while he didn't need surgery, the guy missed diving for eight weeks
while his toe healed. He was wearing leather sneakers at the time of the incident, but one can only imagine
if he was wearing dive booties or going barefoot.
Storing a full tank means that in case of a fire, they're likely to explode. Regardless, divers still store
full tanks, and Burton offers these suggestions:
Either store tanks on their side, or if standing them upright, secure them with a chain, strap or cable
to a stationary building support.
- Close the valves, and keep the protection caps or guards securely in place.
- Store tanks in a dry, well-ventilated area at least 20 feet from combustible materials. Don't keep
them in lockers because if they leak, gas can build up in the locker (and woe to anyone who
opens the door).
- Put them where they're not subject to mechanical or physical damage, heat, or electrical circuits
to prevent possible explosion or fire. Keep tanks away from foot and car traffic.
- Store empty cylinders separate from full ones.
- Get a visible inspection at your dive shop every year, and a hydrostatic test every five years. Retire
aluminum tanks after 10 years.
P.S. Rick Allen is now doing better, but will be in the hospital for a couple of months getting skin
grafts. As owner of Nautilus Productions, he'll be sidelined from his business for a while, so friends and
family started a website to collect donations for his expensive treatments and recovery. Get updates on
Allen's status, and donate at http://getwellrick.com.